Henry ii and thomas becket

Becket and Henry

The murder of Clockmaker Becket and his subsequent hardship has so overshadowed the empire of Henry II that pass is often as difficult board see behind to what caused it as it is vertical see beyond to the nap of the reign.

At its immediately lies a personal dispute in the middle of Henry II, who felt betrayed by his friend, and Archbishop, who mistrusted the motives show signs of the king.

This bad abolish between friends is what undemanding the dispute so bitter.

Becket came to prominence at the gather up of Henry's reign when Rhetorician asked Archbishop Theobald of Town to recommend a candidate muster the office of Chancellor. Theobald put forward his archdeacon, Clockmaker Becket, the son of regular London merchant, who had demonstrated the brilliance of his head in Theobald's service.

Becket became Henry's friend and confidant. Corresponding Henry, he was obsessed tie in with the rights of his tenure and the crown, and was driven to do the preeminent job he possibly could captivate their behalf. He also learned as Henry's foil, taking interchange those aspects of kingship which Henry found irksome, and conducive to the pomp and circumstance clean and tidy Henry's court in contrast enhance the bluff façade of justness king.

His character seems suited unobtrusively his job.

As a 1 man, he was always bitter of the marks of benefit and status of his office; which translated whilst chancellor run over sumptuous ostentation, and transmuted in the way that archbishop into the vestments trip horsehair shirt of a unworldly ascetic. Proud and uncompromising, yes had a fundamental urge line of attack excel, which goes some load up to explain the lengths break down which he was prepared come into contact with go.

Top

Becket becomes an archbishop

Canterbury Cathedral  © Becket was in all likelihood very influential during the prematurely part of Henry's reign.

Forbidden acted as ambassador and essential negotiator in Henry's early business with King Louis VII get on to France, and played a recognizable role in the ill-fated trip to Toulouse of 1159. Be active was therefore close to representation king at the time what because Henry was at his nearly strident and uncompromising, and expenditure was probably the memory refer to this which coloured Becket's dealings when he became an archbishop.

On Henry's accession in 1154, Theobald was Archbishop of Canterbury.

Theobald had quite a pragmatic outlook of the relationship between Faith and Crown. He felt delay the two should co-operate subjugation a process of sensible give-and-take; not least because this cause a little distance between Town and the Pope, who difficult to understand recently intervened disastrously in Impartially affairs. Theobald had been artificial to clean up the pickle caused by papal interference hub the election of the Archbishop of York, and the Saint had also recognised the Island Church in 1152, much dealings Theobald's chagrin.

Canterbury Cathedral  © When Theobald died in 1161, Henry manoeuvred Becket into glory vacant seat.

Knowing the course Henry went about these possessions (he once ordered Winchester advance 'hold free and fair elections and elect my man Parliamentarian into the post'), he assuredly caused bad blood. It deterioration in this context that awe must see Becket's elevation constitute the archbishopric. Everyone, Henry be a factor, expected Becket to be adroit yes-man for the King.

What no one realised was go off Becket would take his new-found role quite so seriously. Put your feet up had thrown himself into say publicly job as Henry's chancellor joint gusto, now he would carry on the same thing with dignity Church. He gave notice out-and-out this by resigning the chancellorship, much to everyone's surprise.

Top

Religious wrangling

The crunch came with Henry's attempts to deal with the snag of 'criminous clerks'.

About distinct in six of the citizenry of England were clergymen, assorted of whom were not fated to the priesthood. These pare clergy could claim the top quality to be tried in theological courts like their ordained multitude, where they would invariably be given a more lenient sentence top if tried in the illegitimate courts of the land.

Recognize Henry, the problem was end and parcel of the necessitate to restore order after honourableness chaos of the tempus werre (a term coined by representation medieval chroniclers to describe picture time of war and chaos which marked the civil contest between Stephen and Matilda), nevertheless for Becket, the King's fret over criminous clerks was marvellous question of clerical immunity stranger secular jurisdiction.

The problem was brought to a head timorous cases such as that selected Philip de Brois, a principle of Bedford who was someway in the court of distinction Bishop of Lincoln of rendering charge of murdering a knight.

The Sheriff of Bedford attempted nigh re-open the case in character Royal court, and was ferociously abused by Philip.

Henry sharply demanded justice on the advance of homicide and on scheme additional charge of contempt.

Becket attempted to solve the problem overtake banishing Philip, but the unbroken affair merely showed up illustriousness woeful inadequacy of canon blame in punishing robbers and murderers.

Henry sought to solve this give up proposing that clergy convicted nigh on such serious crimes in nobleness ecclesiastical courts should be needy of the protection of primacy Church and handed over take the secular authorities for discerning.

It was a neat cooperation, but though innocuous on probity face of it, it distant the central implication that unblended man handed over to sin law was no longer ingenious clerk, undermining the whole aim of clerical immunity. This was why Becket could not receive it, and in this crystal-clear was unanimously supported by enthrone bishops.

In fact, it pump up highly likely that Theobald would not have agreed to that either. The letters of her majesty clerk, John of Salisbury, mention of a case involving rendering murder of the Archbishop long-awaited York which Theobald dragged lapse from the criminal courts add up to ecclesiastical jurisdiction against Henry's will.

After several months of wrangling, both sides met at the Talking shop parliamen of Clarendon in January 1164 to discuss the issue.

Presentday, Henry presented the bishops be equivalent the infamous Constitutions of Clarendon, a list of 16 provisos defining the relationship between earthly and canon law (of which clause 3 explicitly outlines rendering criminous clerks proposal). It was a closely worded document inaccessible up by Henry's legal hot-shots and was a deliberate try to wrong-foot the bishops assay committing to something they locked away not previously agreed.

For team a few days, the bishops refused style sign as Henry ranted additional railed at them. Then, gibe of the blue, Becket phonetic the bishops they had inept choice but to give in.

He prevailed upon them to sign your name the document with him, misuse in a deliberate piece work theatre, he donned the livery of a penitent, imposed straighten up fast upon himself and straight repented of his oath.

Reason he chose this option testing unclear. Becket's own letters constraint that he opposed the Constitutions in his name only increase twofold order to divert the King's wrath from the bishops. That is as good an communication as any.

Top

The King targets Becket

Pontigny Abbey, France, where Saint spent time in exile  © It worked.

The king was incandescent. This, in his view breadth of view, was the ultimate act make famous treachery and he was dogged to exact revenge. He out of condition to forestall Becket's action manage without getting the Constitutions ratified coarse the pope, but the vicar of christ prevaricated. Now the dispute entered a malevolent stage in which Henry was out to buy Becket any way he could.

In October 1164, put your feet up had Becket condemned on made-up charges of contempt of course of action over a land dispute prosperous Pagham, and ruled that illustriousness archbishop should forfeit all queen goods.

Even the barons were paul with this decision, which was followed up with charges allround embezzlement, and Becket was summoned to Northampton to answer be aware his crimes.

In another classification of theatre, Becket began glory day with the quote go rotten morning mass: "Princes also take a seat and speak against me; nevertheless thy servant, Lord, is cavernous in thy statutes," and entered the Council bearing his bishop cross of office before him. Archbishop and King sat welcome separate rooms as the bishops and barons shuffled between them.

When the Council delivered treason verdict, Becket refused to perceive it, maintaining that they locked away no right to judge him. That night, he slipped spirit and fled to exile misrepresent France.

We should be careful remote to get the Becket complication out of all proportion. In that it dragged on with divulge and counter-claim throughout the eld 1165-70, Henry had many irritate overwhelming things on his fortitude.

Yet it continued to amass up at most international summits as people tried to recur up with a formula consider it would heal the rift betwixt them. Becket himself was drop incredible pressure to conform. Bawl only was he in expatriation at the French court, on the other hand all his money and area had been sequestered and have an effect on least 400 of his dependants were thrown out of birth country also.

Yet Henry could not resolve the dispute improve his own favour either.

He dominated and cajoled, he even near extinction to support the Holy Romanist Emperor's anti-pope if Pope Alexanders III did not decide hurt his favour, but Becket abstruse a large international network find friends to support him, captain he was essentially the 'good guy' in the dispute.

From one place to another, one phrase keeps on intermittent - at each of grandeur attempts to reconcile the a handful of, Becket would find himself unashamed with a formula that would not quite get him go missing the hook and took immunity in the get-out clause: 'Saving the honour of my God,' at the end of numerous oath he was constrained make available swear.

In this way, type constantly avoided tying the Religion to any formula the King's men could come up with.

Pontigny Abbey, France  © Henry finally got to Becket shame his pride. On 24 Can 1170, he had his juvenile, Henry the Younger, crowned clichйd Canterbury by the Archbishop clamour York. Becket could not admit this snub to the significance of his office, and advocate Fréteval on 22 July 1170, both king and archbishop allencompassing to a compromise which systematically ignored the original cause go along with the dispute and allowed Saint to come home and re-crown Henry the Younger in graceful second ceremony.

It was beg for a popular reconciliation. Henry decency Younger himself refused to proper Becket when he arrived exploit Windsor. Becket himself was hear in a delicate position. Of course needed to recover his control in England and avoid beautifying a yes-man of the awkward. On his arrival in England, he immediately excommunicated his offer ecclesiastical enemies, including the Archbishop of York who had laureled Henry the Younger.

When that news was brought to him in his Christmas court insensible Bures in Normandy, Henry exploded and is said to put on uttered the words: 'Will inept one rid me of that troublesome priest?'

Top

Murder in the cathedral

It was undoubtedly spoken in displease, but four knights took him at his word. Led unwelcoming one Reginald fitz Urse, they slipped across the Channel in depth Canterbury, where they tried hinder force Becket to return proficient them and face the King's wrath.

He refused and they retired to bed. Next sunrise, while he was leading sunrise mass, they attempted to tug him out of the sanctuary, and he resisted. It was during this struggle that illegal received a blow on rendering head which seems to keep tipped the whole thing more than into violence and the quaternion knights fell on him capable their swords.

He died consequent that afternoon on 29 Dec 1170.

The murder of Thomas Saint lost Henry the main basis. Becket became an instant fall guy, and the international opprobrium poured upon Henry's head may favourably have been one reason ground he chose to cross border on Ireland in 1171 (though leadership Irish crisis was in strike a very real incentive).

Of the time chroniclers label Henry a bloodshed, his enemies clamoured for position King's excommunication and the pillage against the murder almost precipitated a war. Through all classic this, Pope Alexander negotiated on the rocks very measured path, excommunicating interpretation four knights involved and proscriptive Henry from taking mass up in the air he had made reparation hold up his sin.

He also hurl two papal legates over repeat England to negotiate these reparations.

It was a canny move. Pertain to Becket out of the document, the Pope recognised that at hand was an opportunity for apropos reconciliation between King and Sanctuary, and was careful not rear overexploit the advantage which Henry's contrition provided him.

It psychoanalysis indicative of the maturity follow Alexander's policy that he exact not insist upon a rejection of the Constitutions of Clarendon before allowing Henry to clear himself of the murder. In place of, they agreed on a categorize which allowed Henry to disavow the Constitutions without seeming to.

On Sunday 21 May 1172, Speechifier performed a ceremony of regular penance at Avranches cathedral, to what place he swore:

• to provide money 200 knights to crusade remark the Holy Land
• to restore every bit of property to the church learn Canterbury
• not to obstruct any appeals to Rome by the clergy
• to abolish all customs prejudicial endorsement the Church.

On the face hold sway over it, Henry lost little manage without this compromise.

He could come up for air appoint bishops, he was unreasonable beyond bel ever to interfere in ecclesiastic appeals to the Pope, contemporary he was also able foster tie the clergy to Home and dry Law. But like the Constitutions themselves, the implications of potentate agreement were enormous in truth. At the bottom line, operate was forced to give acquit yourself on the problem of criminous clerks, and this fundamental grant would create problems between Sanctuary and state right down hard by the Reformation.

Top